by Cynthia Germain

At Do Good Door County, we often talk about the little things that make aging joyful—those little routines and relationships that bring purpose and connection to our days. For many people, that joy comes on four legs, covered in fur, and accompanied by a wag or a purr. But the age-old question remains: as we grow older, which is better—a dog or a cat?

The Case for Dogs
Dogs are the extroverts of the animal world. They’ll get you out of the house, rain or shine, and they’ll make sure your neighbors know you exist. Morning walks, afternoon strolls, or spontaneous squirrel chases—they keep your body moving and your spirits lifted.

They’re also fiercely loyal. There’s nothing quite like coming home to a tail that wags so hard, knocking down anything in the way. Dogs remind us that we’re loved, needed, and the absolute center of someone’s universe (even if that someone occasionally chews our slippers).

Of course, dogs do come with demands: they thrive on routine, crave attention, and have strong opinions about dinner time. But in exchange, they offer companionship that can fill a house—and a heart—with warmth.

The Case for Cats
Cats, on the other hand, are the philosophers of the pet kingdom. They teach us about independence and grace—and maybe even patience. They don’t ask for walks or constant attention; they simply are. They’re perfectly content to share your space, observe your habits, and occasionally judge your life choices.

For many older adults, cats are the ideal balance of companionship and simplicity. They bring comfort and presence without demanding much in return (except the good treats and that one chair they’ve claimed as their throne).

Maybe the Real Answer Is… Both?
Because in the end, it’s not really about whether dogs or cats are “better.” It’s about the love and laughter they bring into our lives—and the reminder that aging with purpose often starts with a friend who happens to have fur.